The Hidden Costs of Investing Apps: Fees to Check Before You Start

Expense ratios, advisory fees, transfer fees and spreads: small percentages that add up over the years.

My Finance Tech EditorialNov 2, 20264 min read
Investing Apps

Education, not advice. My Finance Tech isn’t a bank, broker or adviser, and we don’t recommend specific apps or investments. Examples are hypothetical. We may be compensated through links to third parties, which never changes our guidance. Advertiser disclosure · Financial disclaimer

Many investing apps advertise low or zero commissions, but “free to trade” doesn’t always mean free to use. Costs can show up in fund expenses, advisory fees, account charges and even the prices you get on trades. Here’s what to look for before you put money in.

TL;DR

  • Commission-free trading is common, but other costs, like expense ratios, advisory fees and account fees, can still apply.
  • Fees are often shown as small percentages, and those percentages compound over time.
  • How an app makes money, including payment for order flow and spreads, can affect the price you pay.
  • Read the fee schedule and disclosure documents before you sign up, not after.

Expense ratios: the cost inside your funds

If you buy mutual funds or exchange-traded funds (ETFs), each fund charges an annual expense ratio. It’s expressed as a percentage of your investment and covers the fund’s operating costs.

You won’t see a separate bill for it. Instead, the expense is deducted from the fund’s assets, which lowers your returns. That makes it easy to overlook.

Expense ratios vary widely depending on the type of fund and how it’s managed. You can find a fund’s expense ratio in its prospectus or fact sheet, and many apps display it on the fund’s detail page.

Advisory and management fees

If an app manages your portfolio for you, as a robo-advisor or managed account does, it usually charges an advisory fee. This is often a percentage of your account balance per year, deducted automatically.

That advisory fee is on top of the expense ratios of the funds in your portfolio. To understand your total cost, add the two together.

Registered investment advisers must describe their fees in their Form CRS and Form ADV brochure. You can look these up through Investor.gov.

Subscription tiers and monthly fees

Some apps charge a flat monthly or annual subscription instead of, or in addition to, a percentage fee. Higher tiers may unlock features such as retirement accounts, research tools, margin access or human support.

A flat fee can look small, but it may be a large share of a small balance. A few dollars a month on a modest account can cost more, as a percentage, than a typical advisory fee. Check whether you’re paying for features you don’t actually use.

Pro tip: Divide your yearly subscription cost by your account balance to turn it into a percentage. That makes it easier to compare with percentage-based fees.

Account, transfer and other fees

Beyond ongoing fees, look for one-time or occasional charges in the app’s fee schedule. Common ones include:

  • Outgoing transfer fees when you move your account to another firm.
  • Account closing fees or inactivity fees.
  • Paper statement or wire fees for certain services.
  • Margin interest if you borrow to invest, which also adds significant risk.
  • Fees on certain products, such as options contracts, foreign stocks or currency conversion.
  • Instant deposit or withdrawal fees on some platforms.

Regulatory transaction fees may also apply to certain sales of securities. These are typically tiny per trade, but it’s good to know they exist.

Payment for order flow and spreads

When you place a trade, your broker sends it somewhere to be executed. Some brokers receive payment from market makers for routing orders to them. This is called payment for order flow (PFOF).

PFOF is one way some commission-free brokers make money. Critics worry it can create a conflict of interest, because the broker may have an incentive to route orders where it gets paid rather than where you get the best price. Brokers have a duty to seek the best execution reasonably available for customer orders, and they must publish reports on how they route orders.

A related cost is the bid-ask spread: the difference between the highest price a buyer is willing to pay and the lowest price a seller will accept. When you buy at the ask and sell at the bid, the spread is a cost, even if no commission appears. Spreads tend to be wider for thinly traded investments. Some crypto platforms also build a markup or spread into the price you see.

Heads up: Using limit orders lets you set the maximum price you’ll pay or the minimum you’ll accept. They don’t guarantee your order will fill, but they give you more control than market orders.

How small percentages add up

The difference between fees can look trivial in year one. Over decades, it can become meaningful because fees reduce the amount that stays invested and compounds.

The table below is hypothetical. It assumes a $10,000 one-time investment, no additional deposits and a steady 5% annual return before fees, with the total annual fee subtracted from that return. Actual returns vary, and investing involves risk, including loss of principal.

Total annual cost (hypothetical)First-year costValue after 20 yearsDifference vs. 0.05%
0.05%$5$26,282—
0.25%$25$25,298$984
0.75%$75$22,989$3,293
1.25%$125$20,882$5,400
A one-percentage-point fee difference is small in a year and large across a lifetime.

Lower cost doesn’t automatically mean better. Some services charge more for features you may value, like advice or support. The goal is to know what you’re paying and decide whether it’s worth it to you.

Quick checklist

  • Find the app’s full fee schedule and read it.
  • Check the expense ratio of every fund you buy.
  • Add advisory fees and fund expenses for a total cost.
  • Convert flat subscription fees into a percentage of your balance.
  • Look for transfer-out, closing and inactivity fees.
  • Read the firm’s Form CRS and order-routing disclosures.
  • Consider limit orders to manage the price you pay.

Sources

  1. Investor.gov — U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission
  2. Investors — FINRA
  3. BrokerCheck — FINRA
  4. Investment Adviser Public Disclosure — U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission
Editorial note: This guide is general education, not financial, investment, legal or tax advice. My Finance Tech isn’t a bank, broker or adviser and doesn’t recommend specific apps, accounts or investments. Rates, fees and features change, so confirm details with each provider. Financial disclaimer · Advertiser disclosure
The Ledger · every Wednesday

Smarter money apps, in five minutes a week.

One new guide, one security tip and one money tool explained. Free and easy to leave.